1. All Comments MUST be school appropriate!
2. You need to make intelligent comments about the different chapters of the novel.
3. Every comment should be in a complete sentence.
4. It is ok to disagree, but you must give your reasoning and it must not be done in an insulting manner.
5. All inappropriate conduct will be reported to School Adminstration.
Wednesday, January 6, 2010
Chapter 16
Although Jonas does not want to return to the Annex, the choice is not his to make.
Well, think of it this way. You can either take in the pain or all your friends, family, and people dear to you experience all of it at the same time. I would probably be PUSHED into doing it by my peers anyway. (But luckily for Jonas, his peers don't know.)
but they live in a utopian society so no one except jonas will feel anything at all jonas shouldnt go and feel all the pain he feels if he doesnt want to the choice is his not no elses to make for him
I agree with Melissa and Lauren C., they shouln't have to decide if he can do this or that .He is old enough to decide if he wants to make those decisions or not !
I think that being forced to do something you don't want to do is really hard to pretend like you want to be there so theres no telling how he looked there meaning his attitude.
i agree with Danielle... If you dont want to go somewhere i dont think it is right for someone to force you to go.. I mean shouldnt you have a say in the matter! ?
I agree with micahwaffle. If people wanted to to do something, let them. I know it is an utopian society but there should be some freedom of speech or action.
i agreed brian23, because it is you who choose to do it so you have to wait for your own time to do it and you also get to decides if you wan tot do it or not.
This summary is very short but i the book its like 5 to 6 pages.
I SOOOOOOOOOO AGREE WITH LAUREN!! UGHHH..... I DONT LIKE WHEN PEOPLE SAY HE/SHE FORCED ME TO OR MADE ME TO! NO, TO ME, I THINK EVERYBODY HAS THE RIGHT TO DO WHAT EVER THEY PLEASE. I CAN UNDERSTAND HIM BEING FORCED BUT I STIL DIDNT THINK IT WAS RIGHT. I THINK NOBODY CAN REALLY,REALLY FORCE YOU TO DO SOMETHININ YOU DONT WANT TO DO UNLESS THEY GET IN YOUR BRAIN AND CONTROL YOUR ACTIONS.
The book's setting seems to be a peaceful, utopian community, where all possible steps are taken to eliminate pain or confusion. The people are almost always compliant; family units share their dreams and feelings on a daily basis to diffuse emotional buildup. This society remains harmonious by assigning jobs to each individual according to a laborious evaluation of their skill, by matching up husbands and wives based on personality to balance out each other, and only allowing two children, one male and one female, per family unit. There is also a subtle theme of technology having only a minimal role in society; throughout the book, it is taken for granted that Jonas's community is without such technologies as television, or radio, although computers are mentioned at one point and there is a two-way microphone/speaker system used for announcements and surveillance, similar to the telescreens of Nineteen Eighty-Four. Transportation is mostly limited to bicycles; however, cars and airplanes exist in small numbers for the main use of transporting food, possibly from other communities. Lowry describes creating the pain-free world of Jonas' Community in her Newbery Award speech: I tried to make Jonas's world seem familiar, comfortable, and safe, and I tried to seduce the reader. I seduced myself along the way. It did feel good, that world. I got rid of all the things I fear and dislike; all the violence, poverty, prejudice and injustice, and I even threw in good manners as a way of life because I liked the idea of it. One child has pointed out, in a letter, that the people in Jonas's world didn't even have to do dishes. It was very, very tempting to leave it at that.[2] As time progresses in the novel, however, it becomes clear that the society has lost contact with the ideas of family and love, at least in the "more complete" sense at which Lowry hints. Children are born to designated "Birthmothers" and then family units can apply for children. If the family unit applies for the maximum allowed number of two, it will always be one boy and one girl. This is to keep the genders even. After family units have served the purpose of raising the children in a stable environment, they cease to exist, the parents going to a communal housing facility for childless adults, and the children becoming involved in their work and starting monogenerational families of their own, forgetting their foster parents who are growing old. The community maintains this process using pills which suppress emotions, mainly romantic love and sexuality, which they refer to as "Stirrings". All the land near the Community and around the other, similar communities clustered about the nearby river has been flattened to aid agriculture and transportation. A vaguely described system of weather control is used so that the weather remains constant. It is implied that genetic engineering has been used extensively to manipulate human beings so that they are all colorblind, and physically conform with Sameness. The Community is run by a Council of Elders that assigns each 12-year-old the job he or she will perform for the rest of his or her life, with a ceremony known as the Ceremony of Twelve, where all Elevens (eleven-year-olds) turn into Twelves. People are bound by an extensive set of rules touching every aspect of life, which if violated would require a simple but somewhat ceremonious apology. In some cases, violating the rules is "winked at": older siblings invariably teach their younger brothers and sisters how to ride a bicycle before the children are officially permitted to learn the skill. If a member of the community has committed serious infractions three times before, he or she may be punished by "release". "Release" is a procedure which is hinted at by the characters throughout the book. Originally, it is thought of as a process where the "released" is sent to live outside of the community (known as Elsewhere in the book), but still in a good place. Eventually, it is revealed to be a system of euthanasia through lethal injection, employed not only as punishment, but also to ensure a monotony of means by which death occurs. The book is told from a third-person limited point of view. The protagonist, Jonas, is followed as he awaits the Ceremony of Twelve. Jonas lives in a standard family unit with his mother (a judge), his father (a "Nurturer") and his seven (later becomes eight) year old sister. He is selected to be "Receiver of Memory", because of his unusual "Capacity to See-Beyond", which is an ability to do something unusual, such as see color, which the other people cannot. This is noted in the fact that Jonas has lighter colored eyes, which only a few people, such as Jonas, The Giver, Gabriel, and a 5 year old girl, have. The memories are images from the time before "Sameness". Through the Giver, who becomes his teacher and surrogate grandfather, Jonas telepathically receives memories of things eliminated from his world: violence, sadness, and loss, as well as true love, beauty, joy, adventure, animals, and family. Having knowledge of these complex and powerful concepts alienates Jonas from his friends and family, as well as making him more cynical towards his previously sheltered life, as he often discusses with the Giver. When he experiences "Stirrings", he is told to take pills to suppress his emotions; he does it reluctantly but realizes that he necessarily enjoys them, namely because he has developed feelings for his friend Fiona. Eventually, these revelations prompt Jonas to seek to change the community and return emotion and meaning to the world. He and the Giver plan on doing this by having Jonas leave the community, which would cause all of the memories he was given to be released to the rest of the people, allowing them to feel the powerful emotions that Jonas and the Giver feel. Eventually, Jonas asks the Giver if he ever thinks about his own release. This conversation leads to watching the release of the smaller of a set of twin boys born that morning. Jonas watches in shock and horror as his father talks sweetly to the baby before giving the newborn a lethal injection, and then dumping the body down a garbage chute. During the course of the novel, Jonas's family temporarily houses a baby named Gabriel, because he is unable to sleep throughout the night and disturbs the other babies in the "Nurturing Center". Jonas learns that unlike the other people in his community, "Gabe" can receive memories from Jonas, which he uses to help calm the baby. Because Gabriel still cannot sleep through the night without crying after the extra year he was given to learn how to sleep soundly, he is now destined to be released. Desperate, Jonas flees the community with Gabe. Also, he was given the instructions from the Giver to flee, and release all the memories that he had stored to the rest of the community. At first, the escape seems successful, with all of the search planes finally giving up their search for Jonas. Soon, however, food runs out and they grow weak. Cold and hungry, Jonas and Gabe begin to lose hope, but then remembering the memory of sunshine Jonas was given, he uses it and regains strength. Jonas begins to lose hope the most, as he no longer cares about himself, but for Gabe's safety; it is here that he feels happy as he remembers his parents and sister, his friends and The Giver. Jonas and Gabriel cross a snow-covered hill in the dark and find a sled on top, which Jonas remembers from the first memory he ever received. He and Gabriel board the sled and go down the hill where they hear music coming from some houses. The ending is ambiguous, with Jonas depicted as experiencing symptoms of hypothermia. This leaves his and Gabriel's future unresolved. However, their survival is made apparent in Messenger, a sequel novel written much later.
if you dont want to go somewhere i dont think you should be forced to go. like that is not fare. :)
ReplyDeleteI think that Jonas shouldn't have to go anywhere if he dosen't want to.
ReplyDeleteWell, think of it this way. You can either take in the pain or all your friends, family, and people dear to you experience all of it at the same time. I would probably be PUSHED into doing it by my peers anyway. (But luckily for Jonas, his peers don't know.)
ReplyDeleteThat is a good one Matt.
ReplyDeleteI also think that he dosen't have to go if he don't wont to. I know if i didn't want to go i shouldn't have to go
ReplyDeletebut they live in a utopian society so no one except jonas will feel anything at all jonas shouldnt go and feel all the pain he feels if he doesnt want to the choice is his not no elses to make for him
ReplyDeleteWhat I hate is that he is being forced to do something he doesn't want to do.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Melissa and Lauren C., they shouln't have to decide if he can do this or that .He is old enough to decide if he wants to make those decisions or not !
ReplyDeleteI think that being forced to do something you don't want to do is really hard to pretend like you want to be there so theres no telling how he looked there meaning his attitude.
ReplyDeleteI think being forced to do something is not ok because its your dicision.
ReplyDeletei agree with Danielle... If you dont want to go somewhere i dont think it is right for someone to force you to go.. I mean shouldnt you have a say in the matter! ?
ReplyDeleteNow they have to give him some freedom I mean It's like they're slaves doing whatever they're told.
ReplyDeletei agree with Daniella too... if you dont want to go somewere, you are not force to go cause is not riht to do that!!!!
ReplyDeleteJonas should have the right to choose at least some things.
ReplyDeleteIf i shouldnt want to go the annex you shouldnt have to. You should be able to go were want to go
ReplyDeleteI agree with micahwaffle. If people wanted to to do something, let them. I know it is an utopian society but there should be some freedom of speech or action.
ReplyDeleteman if he cant choose than this is wrong
ReplyDeleteHe should be able to choose.
ReplyDeleteI dont htink that he has to do anything he dosent want to but i dont think that he has a choice in that place he lives at.
ReplyDeleteI think that if you do not want to do something, you don't have to do it
ReplyDeletei agreed brian23, because it is you who choose to do it so you have to wait for your own time to do it and you also get to decides if you wan tot do it or not.
ReplyDeleteThis summary is very short but i the book its like 5 to 6 pages.
I SOOOOOOOOOO AGREE WITH LAUREN!! UGHHH..... I DONT LIKE WHEN PEOPLE SAY HE/SHE FORCED ME TO OR MADE ME TO! NO, TO ME, I THINK EVERYBODY HAS THE RIGHT TO DO WHAT EVER THEY PLEASE. I CAN UNDERSTAND HIM BEING FORCED BUT I STIL DIDNT THINK IT WAS RIGHT. I THINK NOBODY CAN REALLY,REALLY FORCE YOU TO DO SOMETHININ YOU DONT WANT TO DO UNLESS THEY GET IN YOUR BRAIN AND CONTROL YOUR ACTIONS.
ReplyDeletei probably would not have gone if i didn't want to.
ReplyDeleteIf i didn't won't to do it i would not done it.
ReplyDelete